Heavyweight Title Fight: Hostels vs. Couchsurfing

We all love saving money, especially if that money can then go directly towards funding our travels, or our next travel adventure. Perhaps the biggest expenditure on the road is a toss-up between food and accommodation, and in this article, we’re going to explore the latter. Here we present the pros and cons of two of the big boys on the block – the heavyweight fight between hostels and couchsurfing

girl on a bed

Let’s assume everyone knows what a hostel is – but many people are surprisingly still unaware of couchsurfing, in spite it being around over twelve years. Couchsurfing is a website whereby you create a profile, and depending on your circumstances, you either ‘host’ – which means you allow someone to come and stay in your home for free; or you ‘surf’ – which means you’re the one that is staying at a host’s house for free. You can add and receive positive or negative references depending on your experience – which makes it easier for people to choose to host a traveller, or choose to surf with a host. All clear? Good. Let’s continue.

bed

So we put the two forms of cheap accommodation in the ring to see who would come out on top. By choosing a series of “rounds”, and making a non-biased decision for who wins each bout. DING! DING! SECOND OUT! ROUND ONE!

#1 Price

Even the cheapest and coolest hostels in the world can’t compete with something that’s free. Although couchsurfing has other advantages, perhaps the biggest perk is you could potentially travel indefinitely if you wanted to.

happy girl and boy in a hostel japan

Especially if you’ve got a really solid, positive profile and you’re a lovely person to be around! Even a hostel charging $2.50 a night in Cambodia will soon add up. It’s a no-brainer.

Winner: Couchsurfing

#2 Ease and peace of mind

Check out a hostel on the internet, for example HotelsCombined. Read review. Like hostel. Book it. It’s that simple. Couchsurfing, on the other hand, has a multitude of hoops you need to jump through – which is a nightmare if you’re pushed for time or doing something last minute.

a guy working on a bed in a hostel

You’re never sure if a host is going to get back to you – and there are always the horror stories of someone who has an agenda in offering you a place to sleep, or someone not turning up and leaving you soaking wet in a thunderstorm. It’s got a lot to do with safety and security – and rightly so – but for speed, efficiently, and peace of mind, there’s only one victor here.

Winner: Hostel

#3 Meeting new friends

This is an interesting one – and it depends on your individual experience. There are loads of people in a hostel and you can pick and choose who you talk to, get on well with, want to marry or never want to see again.

 great dubai couchsurfing experience

Friends for life are easily made. With couchsurfing, there’s a pressure to get on with one or two people. If you don’t gel – it could be awkward. However, you’re most likely staying with a local – and locals know their city. You could be in for a wild time with all their mates or see some amazing sites because of that special local knowledge. This round was a close call.

Winner: Tie

#4 Freedom

In a hostel, you can mostly come and go as you please. Sometimes this can be tricky if there isn’t a 24-hour reception, it’s 4 am and you’ve lost your key-card. But for the most part, you’re paying for a service, and you don’t have to ask to go to the toilet. Staying in someone’s home can sometimes feel like you’re walking on eggshells.

hostel in tokyo

Unless they’re willing to give you a key (only reserved for the most trusting hosts) then you’re at their mercy for when you need to be there. Their house, their rules. Hosts often work too – which means you might be waiting on the doorstep to get back in. That’s not really very nice.

Winner: Hostel

#5 Safety and Security

Couchsurfing has come under fire because of a handful of high-profile assaults and even murder cases – but those are isolated incidents. So long as you’re hosting or surfing with someone who has a full profile with decent reviews, there won’t be a problem.

hostel bed japan

Just use your head. Hostels, unfortunately, aren’t immune to dodgy stuff happening there either – everyone knows someone who has had their belongings go walkabout.

Winner: Couchsurfing

Overall

Couchsurfing has its merits. It can be a wonderful cultural exchange, and you get the chance to stay with and see how a local lives. And being cost-free is a big bonus obviously. But it’s just such a hassle – especially if you’re doing it consecutively – and hosts do really hate those “copy and paste” couch surf requests.

hostel in hiroshima

You’ll be tearing your hair out in no time. Hosteling has its downsides too. They can be noisy, filled with people you might not get on well with, and looking after your stuff can cause you stress, especially in bigger hostels. It’s been a close battle, and although the rounds were tied, we’ve decided to award it to hostels on points. We like our freedom.

the warsaw hostel,poland

What would be your winner in this case: hostel or couchsurfing?

Get insured

Accidents and mishaps are often a part of travelling abroad, and so you shouldn’t forget to cover yourself and your belongings for any eventuality. Jump over to our budget travel insurance page and get clued up on who we use as our vital travel safety net.

And while we’re at it, we have a special, dedicated etramping page over at Agoda for booking hotels and hostels. Our readers get 10% off! Just follow the link, and enter the code AGODAETR10 (you need to enter this code before payment, case-sensitive). Honestly, we’re really too good to you!

Tags from the story
,
More from Agness Walewinder

Beijing’s Calling 1/2

Our epic journey during May Day holiday to Beijing. Part 1/2.
Read More

10 Comments

  • i think that i would have liked couchsurfing had i ever given it a go. probably was too scared too. Dont like the idea of staying for free – what if your host doesnt like you? could be awkward for days. And wouldnt be brave enough to offer a place to someone either, and I always felt you need to be prepared to reciprocate to do it. Although I have met people through couchsurfing – just not stayed with people.

    Airbnb seems a nice idea cause people get a bit of money for their time and effort and to me that only seems fair.

    • Well, if the host doesn’t like you then 1) say goodbye to him/her and find your own place (hostel/hotel) 2) take a deep breath, keep calm, do yoga and stay with him/her until the last day :) or 3) get him/her drunk to break the ice LOL (joke)

    • It is a great solution, indeed and you can read more about it in our other posts. You should definitely give it a go soon.

  • I’ve noticed that couchsurfing might be better for staying in more well-known areas like cities or near tourist sites since outside of those areas where not as many people go there are a lot less. Also I’ve noticed there are a lot of people on that site seem to not log on for months at a time. Hostels are great if you want partying since there are so many party hostels out there.

    • I haven’t logged on the site for a long time, to be honest, but thanks for reminding me! I really want to get back on the track of hosting people when I move to Europe.

  • I have to admit I’ve not tried couchsurfing before but I think it’s a fabulous concept for travellers. Also love housesitting too as an alternative option.

  • I’m about to head to Europe as a solo traveller. Hostels appeal more to me because they’re in my comfort zone however I’ve heard amazing things about couch surfing so this will be interesting to try both and see where it leads. Another way of free accomodation I’ll be using is workaway.com – Free accommodation and usually food in exchange for a few hours of varied work in unique locations.
    Once I’ve tried all of the above, I’ll let you know my fave!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *